ETFs vs Managed Funds vs Index Funds

When it comes to investing, the terms ETFs, managed funds, and index funds can be a bit confusing. Let’s break it down simply:

1. Stock Selection Style: Index-Tracking vs Actively Managed

Index-Tracking: Think of this as “set it and forget it.” An index fund tracks the performance of a market index, like the S&P ASX200, which represents the top 200 companies in Australia. You get a slice of every company in the index, and your returns reflect the overall market performance—no guesswork.

Actively Managed: This is when fund managers pick stocks they think will outperform the market. They charge higher fees because they’re putting in the work, but studies show that over time, most active managers underperform the index, especially after fees. Plus, you run the risk of relying on one person’s decisions.

2. The Structure: What Type of Fund Is It?

The three main structures you can invest in:

Managed Funds: A company holds the underlying shares, and you invest by buying directly through them. Both index-tracking and actively managed funds are available. You can find the index funds by looking for “index” in the name.

Examples: Vanguard Australian Shares Index Fund, Colonial First State Global Share Fund.

ETFs (Exchange-Traded Funds): These are essentially publicly listed managed funds that trade like stocks on the stock exchange. You buy shares in the fund through a broker.

Examples: Vanguard Australian Shares Index Fund (VAS), Magellan Global Equities Fund (MGE).

LICs (Listed Investment Companies): These are like ETFs but with a twist—when you buy shares, no new shares are created. The company buys or sells underlying shares at their discretion. This can lead to price changes that don’t always reflect the underlying value, creating potential risks (like buying at a premium).

Examples: Australian Foundation Investment Company (AFI), Argo Investments Limited (ARG).

3. ETFs vs Managed Funds: Which One is Better?

ETFs:

Advantages: Lower tax impact, easy to buy and sell during trading hours, better for large trades. They’re more tax-efficient because capital gains are only realized when you sell your ETF shares, not when others sell.

Disadvantages: You need to save up to make larger purchases to avoid high brokerage fees on small trades.

Managed Funds:

Advantages: Can buy in small amounts without incurring brokerage fees, priced only once a day, making it easier to detach emotionally from short-term market movements.

Disadvantages: Higher tax inefficiency, as capital gains are triggered when other investors sell, not just when you do.

4. When to Buy: Frequency and Cost

With managed funds, you can invest as often as you like without extra costs.

With ETFs, you’ll face brokerage fees each time you buy or sell, so it's better to make larger purchases less frequently to keep costs down.

For example, if you invest $1,500 per month across 3 funds, buying every month will cost you $30 in brokerage. Waiting two months to invest $3,000 would only cost $10 in brokerage, which is much cheaper.

Final Thoughts

-  ETFs are great for low costs and tax efficiency, especially for larger trades.

-         Managed funds are better for smaller, frequent investments without worrying about brokerage fees.

-          The key is to decide if you want to track the market (index) or try to pick winning stocks (active management), and pick the structure that works best for your investment style.

In short, there’s no one-size-fits-all—choose what fits your needs, whether you prefer convenience, tax savings, or trying to beat the market!Top of Form

Bottom of Form